The Risks and Hazards of Retractable Gear Aircraft - SOLVED

By Eric Hardcastle, Instrument-rated private pilot and software builder | Published 2026-11-08

A gear-up landing rarely hurts anyone. It does ruin the propeller, usually sends the engine to a shop to be taken apart, grinds through the belly and keeps the airplane on the ground for weeks. For owners, renters, clubs and flight schools that fly retractables, it is also a big part of why the insurance bill is higher than it would be for a fixed-gear airplane.

Below: how often gear-up landings happen, why, what one costs, how underwriters price the risk, and what prevents them, including the GEAR DOWN reminder we have added to the Flight Suite EFB, and what it can and cannot do.

How common are gear-up landings?

More common than the accident statistics suggest, because most of them never become NTSB accidents. Under 49 CFR 830.2, an aircraft accident needs a death, a serious injury or "substantial damage." The same section says that ground damage to propeller blades, bent fairings or cowling, dented skin, and damage to landing gear, wheels, flaps or wingtips are not substantial damage. A belly landing on a paved runway often stays inside that list.

So the most useful counts come from outside the NTSB database:

  • AOPA Air Safety Institute, 2016. Starting in 2014, ASI logged gear-ups from the FAA's weekly preliminary reports. For calendar year 2016 it counted 159, "and might have missed a few." Fewer than 10 percent of them reached the NTSB accident database (David Jack Kenny, "The cost of non-accidents," AOPA, June 2017).
  • NASA ASRS, 2013. The Aviation Safety Reporting System said in CALLBACK issue 399 (April 2013) that it had received an average of 60 gear-up landing reports a year over the previous five years. Reporting is voluntary, so that is a floor.
  • Insurance claims, 2020. Richard McSpadden, then executive director of the AOPA Air Safety Institute, wrote in June 2020 that gear-up landings were "the second most-claimed incident," and that gear-ups and gear collapses together were "our most costly problem in GA." He based this on conversations and limited data shared by insurers, and said it was not a scientific study.

None of these is a current rate, and we have not found a newer published count. They agree on the shape of the problem: frequent, expensive, rarely injurious, and mostly invisible to accident databases. A search of the NTSB's CAROL database shows only the gear-ups that met the accident definition.

Why gear-up landings happen

Of the 159 gear-ups ASI counted in 2016, five were deliberate or caused by equipment failure. In the rest, the pilot did not put the gear down, and most of those pilots "point to distraction in the traffic pattern or during the approach." Bruce Landsberg put it plainly in AOPA's Flight Training in 2001: "Anything that breaks the landing routine is a setup for the slide."

What breaks the routine is usually something ordinary:

  • Distraction. Traffic, a radio call, a passenger. In one of Landsberg's examples, a pilot busy on short final was also watching a student holding at the threshold, who "decided he could squeeze in the takeoff." The gear warning horn was "sounding in the background."
  • A checklist interrupted. A flow stopped halfway often resumes at the wrong step, or never resumes.
  • A change of plan. A go-around, a change of runway, a straight-in or a short approach moves the point where you normally lower the gear, or removes it. In "The power of habit" (Flight Training, October 2016), a Bonanza pilot describes an unplanned short approach after which "the checklist went out of the window" and habit took over.
  • Habit from fixed-gear time. Most pilots learn in fixed-gear trainers, where the before-landing flow has no gear in it. The FAA's list of frequent transition errors starts with "neglected to extend landing gear." It adds that the same mistakes are made by pilots "who have developed a sense of complacency over time."
  • A warning horn that does not help. The Airplane Flying Handbook (FAA-H-8083-3C), Chapter 12 explains that the horn is normally linked to throttle or flap position, airspeed, or both. It sounds when the airplane is configured a certain way, not when the airplane is near the ground with the gear up. In a CALLBACK 399 report, a pilot counted on the horn and it never sounded: with flaps at 20 degrees and manifold pressure at atmospheric, its conditions were not met.

What a gear-up landing costs

The propeller strike and the engine

A propeller that touches the runway is a prop strike. Lycoming's Mandatory Service Bulletin 533D (February 10, 2026) applies to all Lycoming reciprocating engines. Its time of compliance is "before further flight." It counts as a strike any propeller contact with a solid object while the engine runs, the ground included, and any incident in which the propeller needs repair. Its inspection checklist begins: examine the propeller, remove the propeller, remove the engine, disassemble the engine. It also says Lycoming does not take responsibility for returning a struck engine to service: that decision belongs to whoever returns the aircraft to service.

Continental Aerospace Technologies publishes its own after-strike inspection bulletin (SB96-11). Ask your shop which revision is current and how it applies to your engine. Either way, plan on the engine coming off the airplane.

The propeller and the airframe

Kenny's 2017 article lists the usual items: the propeller, often a constant-speed one, and an engine teardown that can turn into an overhaul or a replacement. On the airframe, damage can reach the belly skins, bulkheads, stringers, flaps, gear doors and gear components. Antennas mounted on the belly are in the way too. On a twin, the engine and propeller costs roughly double.

The downtime

Teardown, parts and sheet-metal work take time, and the airplane earns nothing while it waits. Record the damage as a grounding squawk the moment the airplane stops, so it comes off the schedule: in Flight Suite HQ's maintenance tracking, a squawk can be filed at check-in or with Quick Squawk, with photos, and can ground the aircraft. When the repair bill gets close to the airplane's value, Kenny notes, insurers may decline to pay for the repair, and some repairable airplanes are scrapped. For what happens in the first hours and days after an incident, see our guide to what happens after an aircraft accident.

The one dollar figure we can attribute is McSpadden's: about $70,000 per gear-up or gear-collapse incident, based on what insurers shared with him in 2020.

Why insurance costs more for retractable gear aircraft

AOPA's Air Safety Institute says it directly in its "Staying insured" material: "Gear-up landings are costly. From an insurance perspective, fixed-gear aircraft represent significantly less risk." Underwriters price that risk through a few factors:

  • Hull value. In AOPA Pilot (October 2009), Ian Twombly wrote that the hull accounts for 60 to 75 percent of the annual premium. A retractable is often insured for more than a comparable fixed-gear airplane, and a gear-up is a hull claim.
  • Time in type. The same article calls a pilot's time in type "the single biggest factor in determining that premium." Ratings, the make and model, and the airplane's complexity and performance round out the quote.
  • Retractable time and transition training. In guidance published on AOPA's site by AssuredPartners Aerospace, AOPA's insurance partner, most insurers look for at least 10 hours of dual instruction with an instructor experienced in the airplane when a pilot moves from fixed to retractable gear. The premium "may be a bit higher the first year" and "often decreases at renewal once you've logged over 100 hours in retractable gear."
  • Recurrent training and claims history. ASI notes that insurers view formal recurrent training favorably even when it is not required, and that a clean record with the same insurer over several years improves the odds of keeping coverage.

Minimums differ by insurer and change often, so we quote none. If you rent or fly a club's retractable, the owner's policy usually sets the experience and checkout you need to be covered. Read it. Our article on why renters need their own aircraft rental insurance explains where a renter can be left exposed.

What prevents gear-up landings

No single defense is enough. Stack several, so that one distraction cannot remove all of them.

A checklist and a fixed point in the pattern

The Airplane Flying Handbook calls for "the deliberate, careful, and continued use of an appropriate checklist" in a retractable. It says to complete the before-landing checklist on downwind, to lower the gear by the point opposite your intended landing spot, and to pick a set place on downwind to do it every time. The pilot in "The power of habit" drew the same lesson: lower the gear at the same point on every landing, stop-and-gos included.

GUMPS, and the gear-down call on every leg

GUMPS is a final check: Gas, Undercarriage, Mixture, Propeller, Switches (some pilots use Seatbelts for the S). ASRS notes that it is a final check and "should not be used as a substitute for the specific aircraft's" checklists. In Avemco's "Tick Tick Scrape" (May 2026), Gene Benson recommends running GUMPS on downwind and checking the gear again on base and on final, with a hand on the gear handle until you see three green lights. Saying "gear down, three green" aloud on each leg is harder to skip than a glance.

A stabilized-approach gate

Set a gate: fully configured, gear down and checked, by a height you choose, such as the 1,000 feet AGL Benson suggests. If you are not configured at the gate, go around. That turns a forgotten gear handle into a second pattern instead of a belly landing. Then leave the levers alone until you have cleared the runway: the handbook's advice, and the habit that prevents a retraction on the rollout.

Training and recurrent checkouts

Under 14 CFR 61.31(e), acting as pilot in command of a complex airplane generally takes logged ground and flight training and a one-time logbook endorsement. That is a minimum. A recurrent checkout in each retractable, with an emergency gear extension and an interrupted pattern flown each time, trains for the moment a gear-up actually happens.

Audible reminders that do not depend on the throttle

The aircraft's gear warning system is the primary alert, and it should never be ignored or second-guessed. Its weakness is that it keys off throttle, flaps or airspeed. A second reminder tied to where the airplane is, rather than how it is configured, covers a different gap.

The GEAR DOWN reminder in the Flight Suite EFB

We added a GEAR DOWN reminder to the Flight Suite EFB. Here is what it does:

  • It works for an aircraft marked retractable in its profile. For any other aircraft it stays off.
  • On every approach to the route's departure or destination airport, within 2 nm of the airport and below 500 feet above it, while not climbing, it shows GEAR DOWN in red across the flight strip and says "Gear down!" aloud.
  • It repeats every 5 seconds, four times in all, until you tap "Gear down ✓" or land.
  • It stays quiet on the takeoff roll and climb-out, and re-arms for the next circuit, so it calls on every touch-and-go.
  • It is on by default for a retractable, with a switch on the flight strip to turn it off.

Because it keys off position and height, not throttle or flaps, it calls the same way on any approach. Two limits matter. First, it is a reminder, not a gear warning system: the app cannot see the gear position, so it calls on every approach whether the gear is down or not. Second, it watches only the route's departure and destination airports, and it calls on short final. Your gear check still belongs on downwind.

It is on the website now and comes to the iPhone, iPad and Android app in its next update. Pilots without a flight school can use the EFB on its own for $8 per month after a 14-day free trial.

Can a gear-down reminder lower your insurance premium?

We do not claim it will. Insurers price on pilot experience, training and claims history, and we know of no insurer that publishes a credit for an app reminder. What is true:

  • A claim you avoid keeps your record clean. A gear-up claim follows the pilot and the airplane into later renewals; the gear-up that never happens is the surest premium benefit there is.
  • Some insurers publish training credits. Avemco's Safety Rewards program, for example, offers 5 percent off the annual premium for completing an FAA WINGS knowledge course, another 5 percent for recognized training beyond FAA minimums, and the full 10 percent for a new pilot certificate or aircraft rating. All credits are subject to its underwriting guidelines (Avemco's website, checked November 2026). Other insurers differ, so ask yours.
  • A documented safety program is worth raising with your broker. Ask whether a written gear-check procedure, recurrent checkouts, WINGS participation and layered reminders count at renewal, and keep records of each. A school or club can log them alongside its safety reports and corrective actions in its safety management system, so the evidence is on hand when the broker asks.

An app reminder does not replace the aircraft's own gear warning system, your checklist or your training. It is one more layer, and it only works with the others in place.

Frequently asked questions

How common are gear-up landings?

More common than NTSB data shows. AOPA's Air Safety Institute counted 159 gear-ups in 2016 from FAA preliminary reports, and fewer than 10 percent met the NTSB accident definition.

Does a gear-up landing require an engine teardown?

Usually, if the propeller touched the runway. Lycoming's Service Bulletin 533D calls for removing and disassembling the engine before further flight after a prop strike, and Continental publishes its own bulletin. Your mechanic decides the return to service.

Why is insurance higher for retractable gear aircraft?

Gear-up landings are frequent, costly hull claims, and retractables often carry higher hull values. Underwriters also weigh time in type, retractable time, recent training and claims history, so a pilot new to retractables usually pays more at first.

Will a gear-down reminder app lower my insurance?

Not directly, and we do not claim it will. Insurers price on experience, training and claims. Avoiding a gear-up keeps your claims record clean, and you can ask your broker whether a documented safety program counts at renewal.

What is GUMPS?

GUMPS is a final pre-landing check: Gas, Undercarriage, Mixture, Propeller, Switches or Seatbelts. Run it on downwind, check the gear again on base and final, and use it alongside the aircraft's own checklist, not instead of it.

Flight Suite HQ

Loading…